The Law Reform Commission
of Hong Kong issued a consultation paper on
Guardianship and Custody in December, 1998. Below
is our response to the consultation
paper:
Comments on Consultation Paper on
Guardianship and Custody
The Hong Kong Committee on Children's Rights would like
to submit the following comments on the Consultation
Paper:
1. Introduction
The Committee supports this timely review and
considers it is a good response to the UN
Convention on the Rights of the Child which was
extended to Hong Kong in September, 1994.
Current children ordinances including guardianship
and custody are fragmented. They should be
incorporated into one consolidated ordinance.
Divorce must be seen both as a legal process and a
psychological process that impacts on the child as
well as the parents.
2. Shared parental responsibility after
divorce
The Committee supports the change of language of the
law to emphasize parental responsibility rather than
rights. The Committee also suggests that
parental responsibility should be shared after
divorce for the best interest of the child.
3. Statutory checklist of factors
The Committee supports the recommendations that
judges should have a statutory checklist of factors
to assist in determining the best interest of the
child.
4. Types of orders
The Committee supports the repeal of the existing
orders of custody and the establishment of four new
types of orders, which are residence, contact,
specific issues and prohibited steps order. The
option of 'no order' should also be included if that
is for the child's best interest.
5. The views of the child
Children's views should be taken into account.
Regardless of age, children should be asked whether
they want to give opinion. All involving
parties should be sensitive to children's views and
appropriate channels should be provided for them to
express their views.
6. Representation of the child
Separate representative for the child is recommended
to safeguard the best interest of the child.
7. Third parties/grandparents
Parental responsibility can be delegated to
grandparents and members of the extended family
provided it is in the best interest of the
child.
8. Children's law and policy
A Board or a Commission is recommended instead of a
single policy Bureau, to take responsibility for all
legislation and policies concerning children.
The Board or the Commission which is
multidisciplinary should be given the power to steer
and monitor the policy implementation.
9. Non-adversarial dispute resolution
process
The Committee supports the principal of
non-adversarial dispute resolution process.
Mediation service should be strengthened to involve
all parties to cope with difficulties. We
supports the adoption of a Code of Practice for
family lawyers to ensure a more conciliating approach
to facilitate resolution.
10. Child abduction
Problems of split families between mainland China and
HKSAR should be taken into consideration. Cross
border cooperation should be strengthened to speed up
family reunification and procedures legislated for
cross border cooperation to protect children from
being abducted.
Hong Kong Committee on Children's
Rights
March, 1999
|